Sharia rulings relating to sexuality is neither condemned nor trivialized but recognized as a natural human drive demanding responsible stewardship. This leads to various discussions around various aspects of sexual experience, including the topic of masturbation. Is it categorically forbidden – haram – according to the Sharia, or permitted (mubah) or makrooh (disliked)? The answer requires a deep dive into Islamic sources and scholarship.
This article delves into the discourse surrounding permissibility of masturbation in Islam.
Tracing the discourse surrounding masturbation in Islamic legal and theological thought requires careful attention to specific historical strands and threads within major branches of Islamic scholarship.
Early Schools: Laying the Foundation:
Early scholarship focused heavily on deriving rulings from Quran and Sunnah. In this context, the lack of explicit mention of masturbation led some jurists like Imam Malik and Hanafi scholars to consider it permissible within the bounds of modesty and avoiding harm. Others, like Hanbalis, Ahmad ibn Hanbal and Ibn Taymiyyah, found its discouragement implied in verses and hadiths advocating sexual fulfillment within marriage.
The Influence of Greco-Roman Medicine:
The influx of Greco-Roman medical texts in the medieval period introduced the concept of seminal emissions as vital energy. This influenced some scholars, like Ibn Sina (Avicenna), to view moderate masturbation as potentially harmful to health and intellect. Others, like Ibn Qayyim al-Jawziyya, argued that potential health risks should not override the innate need for sexual release, advocating for responsible self-gratification under certain conditions.
Evolving Discourses and Moral Concerns:
Over time, discussions shifted beyond health concerns, focusing on the potential moral pitfalls of indulging in solitary pleasure. Some scholars, like al-Ghazali, expressed concerns about weakening self-control and fueling sinful thoughts. Others, like Sufis, emphasized the importance of maintaining inner purity and diverting sexual energy towards spiritual pursuits.
Modern Re-evaluations:
In recent decades, contemporary Muslim scholars have engaged in renewed discussions on masturbation, grappling with changing social realities and medical knowledge. Some re-examine historical arguments in light of scientific advancements, questioning the validity of claims linking moderate masturbation to physical or mental harm. Others, highlighting the diversity of scholarly perspectives, advocate for adopting a context-sensitive approach, emphasizing factors like marital status, intention, and potential for causing harm.
This historical overview demonstrates that the legal and ethical evaluation of masturbation in Islam is far from unidimensional. It has been shaped by a rich tapestry of textual interpretation, medical understanding, shifting moral anxieties, and evolving social contexts. This complex picture necessitates a nuanced approach, moving beyond simplistic pronouncements of "haram" or "halal" (permissible), and recognizing the importance of responsible individual conduct guided by informed scholarship and self-reflection.
A deeper exploration of the primary sources now follows.
Quran:
No explicit mention of masturbation exists in the Quran. However, some scholars posit that certain verses hold hidden implications for its permissibility or impermissibility. One frequently cited verse is:
“And tell the believing men to restrain their eyes and guard their private parts. That is purer for them. Indeed, Allah is Aware of what they do." (Quran 24:30)
Here, the command to guard one's "private parts" is interpreted by some as encompassing any act that leads to ejaculation outside of marriage. Others, however, argue that the verse primarily addresses adultery and fornication, emphasizing general conduct and self-control rather than specifically targeting masturbation.
Another oft-referenced verse is:
"And those who guard their chastity – Except from their spouses or those their right hands possess, for then indeed, they will not be blamed." (Quran 79:7-8)
This verse clearly defines permissible avenues for sexual release – marriage and ownership. Some conclude that any sexual activity falling outside these categories, including masturbation, is prohibited. However, others emphasize the verse's focus on preventing adultery and fornication, arguing that it does not explicitly address self-gratification.
Hadith:
Similar to the Quran, the Hadith provides a collection of Prophet Muhammad's sayings and actions, some of which are referenced in discussions on masturbation. One commonly cited Hadith is narrated by Sa'id ibn Jubair:
The Prophet (ﷺ) said: 'It is better for one of you to be struck on the head with an adze (axe) of iron than to touch his private parts with lust.' (Sunan an-Nasa'i 5995)
This Hadith, in its literal interpretation, is understood by some as a categorical condemnation of any act involving touching one's private parts with desire. However, others argue that the metaphorical phrase "struck on the head with an adze" emphasizes the severity of sin, not necessarily equating it to self-gratification.
There are several Hadiths that scholars refer to when discussing this topic. For instance, a Hadith narrated by Abdullah ibn Mas'ud (ra) is sometimes quoted, where the Prophet (pbuh) is reported to have said words to the effect of:
“O group of young men! Whoever among you can marry, should marry, for it helps him lower his gaze and guard his modesty (i.e., private parts), and whoever is not able to marry, should fast, as fasting diminishes his sexual power." (Sahih al-Bukhari)
This Hadith is often interpreted as encouraging marriage or fasting as means to control sexual desires, potentially implying disapproval of masturbation.
Another relevant Hadith narrated by Abu Hurairah states:
"Allah forgives my community for their unintentional errors and forgetfulness, and what they are forced to do." (Sahih al-Bukhari 5483)
This Hadith is understood by some scholars to offer potential leeway for unintentional or unavoidable instances of sexual urges or emissions, which could, in some interpretations, encompass acts of self-gratification under certain circumstances.
Both Quranic verses and Hadith interpretations offer contrasting perspectives on masturbation. It is crucial to recognize that these interpretations arise from diverse scholarly schools and individual understandings of religious texts.
Factors like context, language nuances, and varying chains of transmission influence how scholars arrive at their conclusions. Ultimately, understanding the legal and ethical implications of masturbation requires careful consideration of all relevant evidence, avoiding overly simplistic interpretations.
While the primary sources of Islamic law – the Quran and Hadith – offer diverse interpretations, classical scholars have meticulously examined these texts to formulate legal rulings on masturbation. These rulings, often categorized as "makruh" (disliked or discouraged) rather than definitively "haram" (forbidden), reflect nuanced understandings of the issue.
Major Schools of Thought
1. Hanafi School:
Hanafi jurists generally consider masturbation "makruh tahriman," meaning strongly disliked and bordering on prohibition. They base this stance on the following:
However, Hanafi scholars also acknowledge certain exceptions where masturbation might be considered permissible (halal):
From amongst the Hanafis maintained that masturbation is undesirable [makruh], the Hanafi scholar, Ibn Nujaim said in Al-Bahr al-Ra'iq SharhKanz al-Daqa'iq (vol.2, p.293):
"It is mentioned in the collection of fatawa Al-Walwaljiya that there is no harm [in masturbating] if one only seeks to relieve sexual desire (i.e. excessive sexual desire that distracts a person from religious and worldly matters). Also if one is spouseless or has a spouse, yet it is difficult to reach her/him due to certain circumstances. This opinion is also stated in Al-Siraj Al-Wahaj."
2. Maliki School:
Maliki scholars generally regard masturbation as "makruh tanzihan," meaning mildly disliked but not strictly prohibited. Their reasoning includes:
However, Maliki scholars also emphasize the importance of intention and context, suggesting that masturbation might be considered more blameworthy if:
3. Shafi'i School:
Shafi'i scholars adopt a stricter stance, generally classifying masturbation as "haram." They base this ruling on:
Their interpretation of Quranic verses and Hadiths as discouraging any sexual activity outside of marriage.
The potential for addiction and moral corruption.
The belief that masturbation violates the sanctity of one's body and the purpose of sexual organs.
However, some Shafi'i scholars acknowledge exceptions in cases of extreme necessity to prevent greater harm, such as committing adultery or harming oneself.
4. Hanbali School:
Hanbali scholars generally concur with the Shafi'i position, classifying masturbation as "haram." Their arguments include:
However, they also recognize exceptions in cases of extreme necessity to prevent greater harm, such as fearing for one's health or committing adultery.
In recent times, Islamic scholars have engaged in ijtihad (independent reasoning) to re-examine traditional views on masturbation, considering contemporary social contexts and scientific advancements. Some key points in these discussions include:
While no consensus has emerged, contemporary scholars emphasize the need for a balanced approach that considers both textual evidence and the realities of human experience. They encourage individuals to seek guidance from trusted scholars, engage in honest self-reflection, and make informed decisions based on their specific circumstances and spiritual aspirations.
Navigating the discourse surrounding masturbation in Islamic contexts often requires dispelling various misconceptions that distort and oversimplify the intricate nature of this issue. Here are some key misconceptions to address:
1. Masturbation is categorically haram (forbidden) in Islam.
As we have seen, the majority of scholarly opinions categorize masturbation as makruh (disliked) rather than definitively haram (forbidden). This distinction underlines the nuanced ethical considerations involved, acknowledging the absence of explicit textual prohibition while recognizing potential drawbacks.
2. All Muslim scholars hold the same opinion on masturbation.
As demonstrated by the diverse viewpoints of major schools of thought, a broad spectrum of interpretations exists within Islamic jurisprudence. The lack of a universal consensus necessitates individual exploration and informed decision-making.
3. Masturbation automatically leads to physical and mental harm.
This misconception stems from outdated medical understandings and often ignores the role of intention, context, and individual differences. Modern research offers a more nuanced perspective, highlighting the importance of responsible habits and addressing potential concerns through open communication and guidance.
4. Masturbation is solely a cultural issue with no religious basis.
The discussion on masturbation in Islam primarily revolves around interpretations of religious texts and ethical principles, demonstrating its deep connection with religious frameworks. However, cultural understanding and social contexts undoubtedly influence how these religious principles are applied and interpreted.
5. Openly discussing masturbation is inappropriate or taboo in Islamic culture.
While cultural factors often shape the way such topics are addressed, many Muslim communities acknowledge the necessity of open and honest dialogues on sexuality within safe and respectful spaces. Such dialogues, guided by religious values and informed by contemporary knowledge, can empower individuals to navigate these complex issues constructively.
In the next section, we will offer some concluding thoughts on this topic.
Several key points emerge:
Academic Journals:
Books:
Fatwas and Scholarly Opinions:
Great answers start with great insights. Content becomes intriguing when it is voted up or down - ensuring the best answers are always at the top.
Questions are answered by people with a deep interest in the subject. People from around the world review questions, post answers and add comments.
Be part of and influence the most important global discussion that is defining our generation and generations to come